Appraisal governance for lenders, AMCs, and appraisal firms.

Scott D.W. Wiley and Wiley Valuation Advisory LLC. Twenty-five years spent walking into appraisal functions that were undefined, nonexistent, or broken, and building them into something that works, as the appraiser, as the review chair, and from the lender's desk. I build the valuation programs, review operations, and documentation that hold when somebody else is reading the file.

Schedule a Conversation See how engagements work →

The gap

Two industries stop just short of the same problem.

Mortgage compliance consultants know the loan file. They audit origination, servicing, fair lending, and quality control, and most of them have no appraisal competency at all. The largest one I looked at offers loan review, quality control, and expert testimony, and the word “appraisal” does not appear once in its published list of services.

Valuation vendors know the report. They order it, produce it, and score it, and they are the party your examiner is asking about.

Between the loan file and the appraisal report sits everything that actually gets cited: who may speak to the appraiser and in what words, what your review desk is required to catch, how a reconsideration of value gets vetted before it leaves the building, what your file shows about the process a year later. That is the work.

The record

I have done this before, inside other people's companies.

A national lender's Midwest appraisal division, launched from nothing, team hired, infrastructure built, department running. A national AMC that was an idea when I got there and had a desk, a review operation, a compliance framework and a client base when I left six years later. A multi-state AMC built out of a concept. A valuation group I was brought in to diagnose and rebuild. And most recently a non-QM lender, four months old, where account managers across the company were self-ordering appraisals, no central function, no independence controls, no policy, and regulatory exposure on every loan that closed.

I centralised it, established separation, wrote the governance library from nothing, architected the ordering platform, designed the reporting framework, and carried more than seventeen hundred orders a year as the only person doing it, building the thing and running it at the same time.

Those libraries belong to the companies that paid for them and you will not see one here. The method is mine, and the method is what you are buying.

Checked from the outside

Somebody else audited it, and it held.

When a third-party review firm ran secondary-market due diligence on that portfolio for a prospective institutional buyer, the enforced separation between quality control and appraiser independence was identified as a strength of the collateral pool.

I had to argue for that structure internally before it was adopted. An institutional buyer validated it from the outside afterwards. That is what governance is actually for, and it is what I am selling.

What I do

Assess

Readiness & Assessment

Fixed-fee, time-boxed review of where your valuation program actually stands against USPAP, agency requirements, and the current UAD 3.6 mandate. You get findings, severity, and a remediation sequence, not a list of observations.

See the assessment

Build

Governance & Program Build

Standing up the thing that was missing. Appraisal desk, review function, ROV program, AMC oversight program, panel management. Written policy, working checklists, trained staff, and a file that shows the process.

See the build

Hold

Fractional Chief Appraiser

A named appraisal authority on your org chart without the seat. Monthly retainer, six-month minimum. For lenders and AMCs that need someone accountable for collateral and cannot justify a full-time hire.

See the retainer

Who I serve

Lending institutions

Community bank, credit union, regional or national bank, IMB, non-QM. Different platforms, same gap: nobody owns appraisal in writing.

For lending institutions

Appraisal Management Companies

Boutique to national. Where the review desk is now a licensed, disciplinable activity.

For appraisal management companies

Appraisal Firms

Solo to fifteen appraisers. I have run one for twenty-five years.

For appraisal firms

On November 2 the UCDP stops accepting UAD 2.6.

Eligibility is keyed to the submission date, not the appraisal effective date. A 2.6 file submitted on or after November 2 comes back Fatal. Every order still in your pipeline on October 30 is a file you may have to pay for twice.

UAD 3.6 readiness assessment

Why independent

No panel. No order flow. No vendor to protect.

An appraisal management company cannot independently evaluate appraisal management companies. A valuation firm that produces appraisals cannot independently review appraisals. Both arrangements are common and both are visible to anyone reading the engagement letter.

Wiley Valuation Advisory holds no panel, accepts no order volume, takes no revenue from any vendor in your chain, and has no valuation product whose reputation depends on your findings. When I tell you a review desk is not catching what it should be catching, nothing I sell gets easier if you disagree.

The argument

The error is never evenly distributed.

When a model values property at scale, the misses do not scatter. They concentrate, on the assets with no true comparables, at the top and the bottom of the market, on precisely the files a lender is least able to absorb being wrong about. I have watched that from the review chair, from in front of assessment boards on both sides of the table, and from a non-QM desk where the book is made almost entirely of properties the comparables cannot reach.

It is the reason a valuation program has to be built around the assignments that do not fit rather than the ones that do. A program tuned to the median file fails exactly where failure is most expensive.

I publish the standard I work to.

The Assignment Support Governance Standard is a model operating standard for supervision, verification, and workfile discipline on delegated and tool-assisted appraisal work. It is written to be adopted whole by an appraisal practice, imposed as a panel condition by an AMC, or referenced as a collateral governance control by a lender. It is published in full, free, with no form in front of it.

Publishing here first, ahead of anywhere else.

The first conversation is a conversation, not a pitch. Tell me what prompted it and I will tell you whether it is something I should be working on.

Schedule a Conversation